Buy-and-Hold or Miss The 10 Best (+ Worst) Stock Market Days

Updated connected October 25th, 2023

Whenever marketplace volatility crops up, nan financial property starts shilling nan commentary from plus managers astir staying nan people pinch nan buy-and-hold strategy peppered pinch “time successful nan marketplace not marketplace timing” platitudes. Almost each clip I travel crossed 1 of these buy-and-hold vs trading articles, it’s fundamentally guaranteed to person immoderate version of “what happens if you miss nan 10 champion days successful nan banal market?”

And, of course, nan reply is ever that you would person done importantly amended pinch bargain and clasp investing alternatively than trading for immoderate logic and going backmost successful later. Does anyone ever extremity and inquire why you would only miss nan 10 champion days and nary of nan worst days? That seems a small biased. Let’s really spot what happens.

Who Is Buy-and-Hold Good For?

Buy and clasp investing is bully for group who do not person nan time, inclination aliases assurance to do much than nan bare minimum of investing. This is wholly okay.

Is Buy-and-Hold Still a Good Strategy?

Buy and clasp useful complete nan very agelong word if you tin tummy nan volatility and are okay waiting perchance years to get backmost to even.

For those acquainted pinch my website, I’m a large proponent of being tactical successful nan banal market. While I would ne'er urge anyone return all their money retired of nan marketplace astatine immoderate fixed time, I person decidedly advocated for group taking risk disconnected nan table erstwhile it was prudent to do so earlier nan world is falling apart, not after.

With fixed income yields nan highest they person been successful 15 years, an investor’s allocation operation should beryllium reexamined and rebalanced accordingly to their consequence tolerance. TINA is nary longer nan only woman successful municipality (for those not acquainted pinch nan acronym, it intends ‘there is nary alternative’ to stocks), and bonds enactment arsenic a counterweight to marketplace volatility.

One period treasuries are yielding 3% annualized and I-Bonds are yielding 9.62%. These are awesome consequence free returns that haven’t been this bully for astir 15 years!

Why The 10 Best Days Myth Is Misleading

The portion that ever bothered maine astir nan “missing nan 10 champion days” declare of why you should bargain and clasp stocks is that someway you’d only miss nan champion days if you took money retired of nan market. Notice thing successful peculiar astir nan champion regular returns since 1993 (Yahoo Finance data)?

The champion days coincide astir nan aforesaid clip arsenic nan worst days because nan champion days stem from marketplace volatility, not melt ups. Sometimes nan champion and worst days are nan adjacent day, successful fact.

So nan statement pushed by nan plus managers is that you’d someway waste your stocks nan time of a large marketplace washout and past bargain them backmost nan time aft a ample summation and do this consistently without missing immoderate of nan bad marketplace days. This statement is stacking nan platform successful favour of nan buy-and-hold finance strategy.

If you are closing retired your banal vulnerability because of volatility aliases different reason, isn’t it conceivable that you’d miss immoderate of nan bad days too? I deliberation so, which is why I wrote this article. I was funny what nan banal marketplace capacity would look for illustration if you missed nan 5, 10, and 20 champion and worst days.

Stock Market Performance After Missing Best and Worst Days

As a baseline, if you had invested $1,000 successful nan S&P500 done SPY and reinvested nan dividends since Jan 1993 until September 2022, you’d person $14,380, for a compounded return of 9.41% a year, which is inline pinch nan humanities average. Nothing is incorrect pinch buy-and-hold complete agelong periods of time.

Instead, if you someway missed nan 20 champion and worst days, your last equilibrium would beryllium $16,243 for a compounded return of 9.86%.

If you missed nan 10 champion trading days and nan 10 worst trading days, your last equilibrium would beryllium $15,602 for a compounded return of 9.71%.

And, if you missed nan 5 champion and worst days, your last equilibrium would beryllium $34,480 for a compounded return of 12.69%!

It’s really rather singular that you tin miss conscionable 0.13% of each marketplace trading days and amended your return capable to much than double your last relationship equilibrium complete astir 30 years.

Of people it is silly to presume that you’ll beryllium capable to prime retired nan 5, 10, aliases 20 days beforehand. But what does this show you?

Avoiding nan downside is much important than missing nan upside for your agelong word finance strategy, and nan logic is nan volatility drag. What I mean is that if a $1,000 portfolio gains 25% and past loses 25% (or first loses and past gains), nan portfolio isn’t backmost to $1,000, it’s down to $937.50. What ‘avoiding nan champion and worst x days’ shows you is that nan skew of nan portfolio is reduced.

So really mightiness we instrumentality thing for illustration this?

A Simple Strategy To Avoid nan Best and Worst Days

So we person established that nan champion and nan worst days hap astir nan astir volatile times and that taking consequence disconnected nan table during these times tin lead to outperformance complete nan agelong term. So really could we do this without knowing nan future? The reply is simply a very elemental strategy of pursuing nan trend.

Now trends tin beryllium established galore ways and what I coming conscionable shows nan powerfulness of a elemental thought successful method analysis. It’s not a caller idea and various costs and master traders return it into information connected some nan S&P500 and individual stocks: nan moving average. The thought is simple, you bargain erstwhile prices are supra nan moving mean and waste if below.

Some usage a 200 time elemental moving mean and others usage nan exponential. Some mightiness usage nan 150 time aliases nan 250 time and waste and acquisition daily, weekly, aliases monthly. There are galore ways to tegument a feline and each method will person its ain pro’s and con’s but yet they each execute nan aforesaid thing: you are retired of nan marketplace erstwhile it is going down.

The 2 worst drawdowns successful caller history were 2008 and 2000 which some saw nan banal marketplace trim successful half by nan clip nan harm was over. The astir volatile times were besides while nan marketplace was trading nether nan 200 time moving average, which if you mention backmost up to nan tables above, you will spot galore of nan dates for nan champion and nan worst regular returns listed.

Having a azygous moving mean for your awesome tin lead to a batch of chop trading and mendacious positives astir nan line, truthful I for illustration to usage 2 moving averages which slows down nan buying and selling: nan 10 time moving mean and nan 200 time moving average. This useful likewise and each you do is hold for a cross-over of nan accelerated moving mean and nan slow moving average. Buy nan S&P 500 and clasp it erstwhile nan 10 time moving mean is supra nan 200 time moving mean and waste it otherwise. You still get a small chop and mendacious positives, but you tin spot beneath that it dramatically cuts them down, circled successful red.

The champion portion of this strategy is that you debar nan worst parts of a ample downward move and usually nan top volatility.

The 2000-2003 Bear Market was sadistic and buy-and-hold mislaid 50%

The 2008 Great Financial Crisis besides took down buy-and-hold 50%

This is only 1 instrumentality successful nan toolbox and astir traders usage a postulation of signals to thief guideline their decisions.

200 Day Moving Average Strategy Results

So now that we person established nan strategy, really does it perform?

The last relationship equilibrium complete nan aforesaid clip play is $14,109, corresponding to a compound return of 9.31%.

Right astir now you are astir apt reasoning “wait a minute, this last relationship equilibrium is smaller than nan buy-and-hold finance strategy!” And you are right, but 2 points: location were respective years of down periods wherever nan relationship was conscionable holding rate and earning 0%. During these periods it was conceivable that nan investor would person earned astatine slightest 2% annualized successful short long bonds which would person accrued nan compound return somewhat.

Secondly, what I haven’t shown you yet is that nan strategy had 30% little volatility and almost a two-thirds little drawdown risk. What this intends is that you tin lever up nan elemental 200/10 time moving mean strategy to nan aforesaid level of volatility arsenic nan buy-and-hold finance strategy and seizure much return and little downside risk.

The leverage basal to equate nan volatility to nan buy-and-hold strategy is astir 1.5x. A elemental measurement to instrumentality this would beryllium to either usage separator from your brokerage (likely excessively expensive), employment futures contracts depending connected nan size of your relationship (very efficient), aliases stash half your banal rate successful treasuries and half your banal rate into a triple levered money specified arsenic SPXL (technically this wouldn’t beryllium precisely 1.5x because of regular re-balancing, but beautiful close).

Graphically, nan return bid look for illustration this:

Notice really nan levered 200/10 time moving mean strategy bests moreover nan 5 champion and worst trading days ‘strategy’ that requires intolerable knowledge of nan future.

In tabular form, nan pursuing shows nan compound yearly returns, worst drawdown, yearly volatility and return connected risk. Return connected consequence is fundamentally nan Sharpe Ratio, but utilizing a 0% consequence free complaint during nan full period.

Even utilizing 1.5x leverage, nan worst drawdown was little than half what nan buy-and-hold investor would person had.

Now, marketplace frictions specified arsenic transaction costs, slippage and taxes would trim nan aforementioned moving mean strategy results a bit, but pinch astir brokerages offering $0 commissions and nan bulk of astir people’s finance costs wrong status accounts, galore of those frictions could beryllium reduced aliases eliminated.

If you want to publication much and spot various statistic connected leverage and nan 200 time moving average, cheque retired nan published paper that uses a akin but a somewhat different strategy.

Closing Thoughts

The constituent of this study is to show that while buy-and-hold useful good complete agelong periods of time, a elemental method study trading strategy tin outperform it pinch little risk, amended drawdowns, and beryllium wholly retired of nan marketplace during nan astir achy times erstwhile everyone other is panicking and emotion stressed out. Of people you would astir apt only use it to a information of your banal holdings, but nan constituent is for exposition.

The costs of missing 10 champion days successful banal marketplace is only a problem if you missed nan champion days and nary of nan worst days which would beryllium a statistical impossibility. That statement is simply a stacked platform successful favour of being successful nan marketplace astatine each times.

The trading strategy presented present takes consequence disconnected nan array erstwhile it is prudent to do truthful without knowing thing different than nan value action. Even without utilizing a method study trading strategy, sometimes location are very bully reasons for taking risk disconnected nan table. If you person been pursuing my blog, each past twelvemonth I was showcasing why nan banal marketplace looked for illustration a bubble and mentioning nan risks of inflation, deficiency of consequence power and utmost banal marketplace valuations.

Using economical knowledge mixed pinch a method trading strategy tin springiness you nan assurance to execute it without doubting yourself.

I americium not saying that you should instrumentality this strategy but hopefully it gets you reasoning otherwise astir investing and that buy-and-hold isn’t nan only crippled successful town. As always, past results are not suggestive of returns for nan future.

Come subordinate my Telegram chatroom for unrecorded marketplace commentary.